Holiday Pandemic

As the coronavirus pandemic grows worse than ever in the US, here is a summary of guidance on if and how to gather during the holidays:

CDC

  • Staying home is the safest option, avoiding the increased risk of spreading the coronavirus and COVID-19 to your relatives and yourself, but if you must take the risk and gather, consider..
    • Community level: Check the number and rate of COVID-19 cases in the gathering location and where travelers may be coming from and through
    • Location: Outdoor gatherings are less risky (and colder) than indoor
    • Duration: Shorter gatherings are less risky (and less filling) than longer
    • Number: Fewer people pose less risk (and less noise) than large groups
    • Travel: Local trips are safer than distant travels, especially if people are traveling from multiple locations
    • Behavior: Responsible people–who wear masks, maintain social distance, and wash hands–pose much less risk than irresponsible people who refuse these basic preventative measures
  • People should NOT gather if they…
    • Have symptoms of COVID-19 or the disease itself
    • Are still awaiting results of COVID-19 tests
    • May have been exposed to someone with COVID-19 in the previous 2 weeks
    • Are at increased risk of severe illness or death from COVID-19
  • CDC also provides guidance for hosts, travelers and revelers

Wired

  • Staying home is the safest option, given there is no perfectly safe way to gather, but a difficult choice for many families, so…
  • Talk to relatives openly ASAP about how you plan to protect them, your immediate family and yourself
    • Don’t feel pressured into taking uncomfortable or even dangerous risks
    • Don’t judge those who opt out this year
  • People not in the same household (or larger “pod”) pose the same risk to each other as strangers, so maintain social distance and wear masks as you would in public
  • Testing everyone in advance helps mitigate risk, assuming all results are negative, but is not a guarantee, since people may become infected anytime after the test sample was taken, or may get a false negative result (25% of the time with some tests) and still be infectious (this may be the case in some of the White House’s super-spreader events)
  • Eating together increases risk, since people remove masks and spread droplets and vapor by breathing, talking, coughing, sneezing

USA Today

  • Holiday parties potentially spread infections, even if small and only with relatives, as evidenced by infections traced to weddings, funerals, religious gatherings and other everyday group events
  • CDC advice may be mocked by some who feel it infringes upon their “freedom” (to infect?), at their relatives’ and their own peril
  • There is no ideal choice between risks (loss of health and life) vs isolation (loss of in-person camaraderie and rituals this holiday season)
  • Test types: Antigen tests are usually quicker (and sometimes cheaper) but less accurate than “gold standard” PCR tests.
    • My wife and I just took a PCR test with saliva samples that claims 90% accuracy but takes 36 hours for results.
    • The same clinic offers an antigen test that provides results within 15 minutes but with only 75% accuracy (1 in 4 chance of false negative).

Leave a comment