We dumped DirecTV satellite TV several years ago, and have not missed their hundreds of useless, unwatched channels, long term contracts, and overpriced service that frequently cut out during Houston thunderstorms. If you have a fast (> 20 Mbps), reliable broadband connection, consider dumping cable or satellite TV and switching to internet TV, supplemented with broadcast TV. (Yes, broadcast, as in free TV over the airwaves, like the olden millennium, only with far better digital transmission of high-def images and surround sound.) Being a “cord cutter” gives you much more control over exactly what and when you watch, all the better in this golden age of cinema-quality, binge-able TV. Long gone are the days of having to accept the lame programming and rigid schedule of a few broadcast networks. You also may save a little money by replacing your bloated cable or satellite TV contract with a few smaller ($8-40/month) internet app subscriptions…that you can turn on and off each month as you wish (e.g., I pay $25 for Sling TV only during months I want ESPN for particular sporting events).
Brace yourself for the breakup!
When you call a satellite or cable TV company to cancel their service, they usually transfer you to a “retention specialist”, hell bent on retaining you as a customer, perhaps offering you a discounted contract (so, worth doing even if you don’t cancel), keeping you on the phone for however long it takes to change your mind…and thus earn a pay bonus. My DirecTV retention specialist was an impressively persistent but sadly unsuccessful guy named Philip. During our absurdly circular 20 minute conversation, he repeatedly asked, “but why are you giving up TV?!”, as if unaware that TV predated satellites and likely will outlast his company. (I posted my “Ode to Philip” on FB: “we’ve grown apart, Philip…it’s not you, it’s me…you’ll find the right customer someday…”) Be prepared with strength and resolve in your righteous desire to cut their cord.
Hardware & software?
You may need some new equipment and subscriptions for accessing internet TV apps, and a broadcast TV antenna. There are many choices, so I’ll just list what we use and a couple alternatives.
Apple TV: I connect these little black boxes to our internet router with ethernet cables and wifi, and to our TVs with HDMI cables (one box per TV). We use Apple TV to watch internet TV apps (Hulu, Netflix, HBO Go, PBS, Amazon Prime Video, Comedy Central, SlingTV, ESPN, etc.), and to stream video from our iPads and Macs to our TVs.
- Roku is an excellent, cheaper alternative (I’ve used a couple), especially for a non-Apple-centric household, with a much better remote control. (Apple makes many great products, but struggles with peripherals such as remotes and mice.)
- I have no hands-on experience with Google’s Chromecast or Amazon’s Fire TV, and it has been a while since I last compared them to the more popular Roku & Apple offerings. Ask Alexa, Google Assistant, and Siri, and see what they recommend. 🙂
- You may ask, “why do I need another box when my TV already has Netflix?!” Though most “smart” TVs come with a few internet apps built in, I still recommend using an external box such as Apple TV or Roku for a few reasons:
- Security: Apple & Roku update their software far more frequently than TV makers such as Samsung & LG. In our world of relentlessly increasing cyber-threats, you want rapid, continuous fixing of inevitable bugs & security holes.
- Selection: There are far more apps and games available on Apple TV and Roku boxes, and you can easily download new apps, whereas TVs often are stuck with the few apps they came with.
- Speed: TV makers use cheaper, slower computer chips than Apple & Roku.
- Some recent TVs offer built-in Roku or Chromecast hardware. While that’s better than using the TV maker’s crappy interface for internet TV, and may eliminate one remote control, I still prefer an external Roku or Apple TV box, as I upgrade these little boxes much more often than big, expensive TVs. I’ve had my largest Samsung plasma TVs for 6 years, and they still produce great images. During that time, I’ve gone through a few generations of Apple TVs, incrementally improving HW performance and features, which wouldn’t be possible if it were built into my TV.
HDHomeRun EXTEND: this black box by SiliconDust takes the signals from our window antenna and streams broadcast TV channels on our network for easy viewing on our Apple TVs, iPads and Macs (up to 2 devices simultaneously), useful for watching sports and other live network events anywhere in the house.
- I subscribe to SiliconDust’s HDHomeRun DVR service, enabling me to record and time-shift shows like The Late Show with Stephen Colbert that aren’t available in Hulu. (We watch all of the late night talk/comedy shows the next morning with breakfast and coffee, almost never when they’re aired at night.)
- HDHomeRun’s main weakness is supporting software: the HDHomeRun app for MacOS isn’t great, and the InstaTV app on Apple TV is worse. Both are functional, and slowly improving, but still noticeably crappier in stability, usability and appearance than the big internet TV apps such as Netflix, Hulu and HBO Go. SiliconDust offers decent hardware, but really should step up their software game!
- I chose the EXTEND over the other HDHomeRun models for its hardware h264 transcoder which compresses video in real-time rather than streaming raw mpeg2. If you don’t know or care what that means, or you need more than 2 tuners in one box, check out the CONNECT QUATRO with 4 tuners.
- The TiVo BOLT OTA with built-in DVR is a well-reviewed alternative to HDHomeRun for viewing and recording broadcast TV, and even has some streaming apps, making it a very limited alternative to Roku or Apple TV.
Antenna: This is the simplest, oldest and least expensive component of cord-cutting. I use two cheap ($20-40), flat, indoor, un-amplified digital antennas–one connected to my HDHomeRun EXTEND box and the other connected directly to my largest Samsung TV for live events–both stuck in a window facing the huge TV broadcast towers in southwest Houston. My 5-year-old antenna models are AmazonBasics and Mohu Leaf, but there are many good brands these days. If you really want the latest “best” option, WireCutter is my goto source for such reviews and recommendations. However, almost any popular, highly-rated digital antenna should provide good HD reception, assuming you’re close enough to TV towers and can point your antenna at those towers.
- Range: Buy an antenna made for the distance from your house to your nearest TV towers. More range typically requires a larger antenna size and price, and sometimes a powered signal amplifier. If you live way out in the sticks or mountains, you may be too far from city TV towers for reliable reception of broadcast TV…but you knew that already.
- Placement: Place your indoor antenna on the side of the house facing the nearest TV towers, preferably in a window. Larger, longer-range antennas may be placed in the attic, or even on the roof…old school!
Apps: We subscribe to Hulu ($12/month for no commercials), Netflix ($11/mo) and sometimes Sling TV Orange ($25/mo, mainly for ESPN), a total of $48/mo before tax, much cheaper than my old DirecTV bills. Amazon Prime Video is included with my Amazon Prime membership ($10/mo). We use the free version of Comedy Central (mainly for the Daily Show with Trevor Noah), though you could pay for full access. PBS Video is free, though I donate to PBS anyway, because their high quality shows (Frontline, Nova, American Experience, Austin City Limits, etc.). We rent movies in iTunes, and I load up my iPad with rentals before flights. You may subscribe to HBO Now, but HBO Go is already included with my Comcast cable internet/TV bundle ($60/mo for 60 Mbps, recently downgraded from $90/mo for 250 Mbps).
- Why would a cord-cutter still have a cable TV bundle?! Comcast makes their Xfinity internet/TV “double-play” bundle cheaper than internet alone–perhaps to inflate their “TV subscriber” numbers for advertisers despite the growing number of cord-cutters–so I technically have Comcast’s basic TV service with HBO included, though I’ve never used their Xfinity TV box…fun and games with Evil Corp, as Elliot would refer to Comcast.
- YouTubeTV is Google’s competitor for Sling TV. [Updated 2018-10-21] I recently tried it for a week, and liked the high-res live sports and on-demand access to broadcast network shows. However, I couldn’t stand all of the forced, low-res, repetitive commercials, and canceled my trial. For $40/mo, I expect ad-free on-demand viewing. Check out YouTubeTV’s offerings, as they may have the best value for your internet channel needs, including your local broadcast channels, but be prepared for inescapable ads.
- Month-to-month: long term contracts are obsolete in the new world of a la carte internet TV. You may start and stop any of these app subscriptions in any given month. Going on a long trip or taking a TV-free sabbatical? Kill your subscriptions and restart later as needed. In contrast to the old TV “service” companies, the new i-TV norms are convenience and flexibility.
- International travel: Unfortunately, many of the paid subscription apps won’t work when they see you connecting from a foreign IP address. You can try fooling them by routing through a US VPN server, but Netflix and others block VPN connections as well. Freebies and podcasts still work, of course, but be prepared to lose access to premium TV apps overseas. Then again, when touring abroad, what the hell are you doing watching TV anyway?!
Cut that cord and say goodbye to Evil Corp!…unless you are stuck with them for internet access due to an abysmal lack of ISP competition in your area. 